1. Newsroom
  2. Active management makes a comeback
Menu
Expertise 02.03.2017

Active management makes a comeback

Active management makes a comeback

Correlation between asset classes is falling towards normal levels. The recent rise in bond yields and monetary policy normalisation are causing much wider variations between asset classes in terms of their behaviour and returns. Now that these differences are reasserting themselves, active management is likely to outperform passive management.


Passive management, or index-tracking, became much more popular following the financial crisis. A high level of correlation between the various asset classes between 2008 and 2016 worked in favour of the passive investment approach. During that long post-recession recovery period, inflows of liquidity into the markets along with low bond yields, driven by ultra-loose monetary policies, encouraged large-scale buying by investors.

Yield-seeking investors pumped money fairly indiscriminately into segments deemed likely to deliver returns higher than the traditional risk-free rate. As a result, the main asset allocation decisions involved investing in riskier bonds and in equities. As indexes rebounded from their lows, equity investments took place mainly through index-tracking ETFs to the extent that global assets under management in ETFs rose from $750 billion in 2008 to almost $3,500 billion in 2016. The outperformance of the major indexes was self-sustaining, not because of the fundamentals but mainly as a result of money flowing into ETFs.

Market behaviour is returning to normal and decorrelation is making a comeback

Now, however, active management is set to see a resurgence among equity investors. Correlation between stocks is falling towards normal levels, since the recent increase in bond yields and monetary policy normalisation are causing investments to show widely varying behaviour and returns depending on the fundamentals. This means that stock selection is once again adding value, including within individual sectors, since it enables investors to take advantage of sector or style rotation.

As regards style, for example, a "value" stock automatically becomes more like a "growth" stock if its price rises, all other things being equal. As a result, to maintain a pure value strategy, an asset manager needs to take a fairly dynamic approach, refreshing the portfolio regularly by taking profits on holdings that have become growth stocks and reinvesting the proceeds in other stocks that are trading at an unjustified discount. Passive managers only make these kinds of returns-enhancing switches once per year, when the index they are tracking is reconstituted.

Positive momentum for US mid-caps: an argument in favour of active management

Finally, the new US economic policy landscape will also affect the way investors view markets. Tax-based stimulus, massive public-sector infrastructure investment and policies to boost domestic activity in the USA should primarily benefit small- and mid-caps, which have historically been more sensitive to domestic economic growth. Since 1926, the 10 phases of Fed rate hikes – synonymous with economic recoveries – have seen small-caps outperform blue chips. In the 12 months following Fed funds rate hikes, small-caps have returned 14.5% as opposed to 10.5% for large-caps.

And if there is any area in which active management is vital to achieve good returns, it is the small- and mid-cap segment. All of this means that active management is about to make a comeback.


FALLER Nicolas.jpg

Nicolas Faller
co-CEO of Asset Management

 

Expertise

Impact investing - Contributing to a more sustainable future

What are the key features of impact investing?

Read more

Actualités les plus lues

Expertise 10.06.2021

Covid-19: Restez informés avec l'UBP

Depuis l’apparition du coronavirus, l’UBP accompagne et soutient ses clients dans le contexte inédit de cette crise sanitaire mondiale. La Banque vous informe régulièrement de l’adaptation de ses dispositifs aux règles de précaution fixées par les autorités et partage avec vous les dernières analyses de ses experts sur les conséquences de la pandémie pour l’économie mondiale et les marchés financiers.

Expertise 24.03.2021

Gestion discrétionnaire – vous êtes toujours aux commandes

Parce que vos objectifs et vos aspirations sont uniques, nous vous proposons un service de gestion discrétionnaire exclusif.

Expertise 21.12.2020

China: Don’t fret over an increase in corporate bond defaults

Bond defaults were not part of the debate for much of 2020. However, these have picked up steam in Q4-20, resulting in a record level of USD 21.8 billion YTD, far exceeding the previous high of 2018.


A lire également

Expertise 15.06.2021

L’Impact investing sur les marchés émergents post-COVID

Pour les investisseurs en «impact investing», l’année 2020 a constitué un réel «stress test» en termes d’équilibre entre impact et performance financière.

Expertise 11.06.2021

Preparing for the start of a mini-cycle

The recovery phase of the US economic cycle is increasingly mature and looks set to transition to its next phase in the coming months, a ‘mini-cycle’ similar to those seen in the long expansions of the 1990s and in the post-Global Financial Crisis era.

Expertise 10.06.2021

Covid-19: Restez informés avec l'UBP

Depuis l’apparition du coronavirus, l’UBP accompagne et soutient ses clients dans le contexte inédit de cette crise sanitaire mondiale. La Banque vous informe régulièrement de l’adaptation de ses dispositifs aux règles de précaution fixées par les autorités et partage avec vous les dernières analyses de ses experts sur les conséquences de la pandémie pour l’économie mondiale et les marchés financiers.